[ ]   [ ]   [ ]                        [ ]      [ ]   [ ]
Porcupine Tree — Anesthetize
Album: Fear Of A Blank Planet
Avg rating:
7.5

Your rating:
Total ratings: 431









Released: 2007
Length: 17:38
Plays (last 30 days): 0
(no lyrics available)
Comments (179)add comment
Sitting here on a Friday night home alone, wifey's out so the volume knob works again & got FOABP vinyl playing loud - this masterpiece is on right now.... Bill, you've not played this since 2007 according to the log, not sure if that's correct but in any case... play it again Bill :-)

 lagger wrote:
PURCHASED THE CD AND IT JUST KEEPS GROWING ON ME LOVE THE DRUMS
 
yea same here, I didn't like it at first, but it does grow on you in a very nice way.  I didn't read through all the posts, but I hear Radiohead in the first bits of singing.

Way Out Of Here is my current fav with the "Soundscapes of Robert Fripp" - guitar god of King Crimson back in the day

Got my tix for Oct. 10 in Asheville. Can hardly wait.
I'm going to the October 23rd show here in Cincy with a bunch of friends- This will be my third time seeing the band. I can't wait either!!!! Damn 23 days to go :jump: Last time I saw them live (at the House of Blues in Cleveland last May) they played this juggernaut live and holy hell it kicked some serious ass :war: :drummer: :guitarist: :war:
Their drummer Gavin Harrison is jaw droppingly good :drummer:
Sounds like they've got a pretty good drummer. fuh2 wrote:
What an aural journey!
That's what she said. Thank you and good night.
Yet had the luck to see them once... and I'll have it one more time, at the Olympia in Paris! I'm sure it will we great another time. Thx, RP!
:music: :guitarist: :drummer: :music:
I've bought a lot of PT since I came here :smile: - the drumming on this album is back up to speed (thought Deadwing was a little short in the percussion department) - thanks Bill.
ummmmmm...........i'm not getting the link between this and scarborough fair?
What an aural journey! The sounds these guys use are like nothing I've ever heard before. Volume higher and higher.
ziggytrix wrote:
This tune feels a lot more like APC or Rush than Tool. It's a great song, too, don't anyone let my prior comments let you think otherwise. I just don't agree with the Tool-bashing.
Gee, I think they sound like Porcupine Tree. This album keeps growing on me. Love PT and RP!
If you don't think Porcupine Tree are awesome, then there is something very wrong with you and you are different and strange. All your friends think Porcupine Tree are great.
Nice set. Oh. That was all one song... 8. Just the same.
FeydBaron wrote:
Everyone is mentioning Tool, but I heard a section in there was reminded me strongly of A Perfect Circle.
This tune feels a lot more like APC or Rush than Tool. It's a great song, too, don't anyone let my prior comments let you think otherwise. I just don't agree with the Tool-bashing.
I love that even though my boss interrupted this song, it was still playing when he left my office. PT is the best...along with RP, of course!
Got my tix for Oct. 10 in Asheville. Can hardly wait.
A long time ago, I posted a comment that Carter Beauford was god. Now, I know that Gavin Harrison is... ;-)
Wow, do we get the full 17 minutes here on RP? Outstanding. I never knew that Alex was on this. Cool!
:notworthy: :drummer: :notworthy:
lagger wrote:
PURCHASED THE CD AND IT JUST KEEPS GROWING ON ME LOVE THE DRUMS
I need to pick up this album, for sure.
PURCHASED THE CD AND IT JUST KEEPS GROWING ON ME LOVE THE DRUMS
The vocals are not 'weak' per se. They are simply understated. Awesome harmonies all the same.
Actually Alex Lifeson from Rush does play the guitar solo about a third of the way through the song. Wilson does all the rest of the guitar work though :bounce:
Awesome song.
Atombender wrote:
Great stuff, but I think the singer is quite weak in the whole ensemble. The drummer makes me want to practice more on my drumset! Eight eight eight!
SW is actually quite the vocalist. There's an acoustic version of Sentimental (the track that follows this on on the record) floating about that is simply stunning. But you are quite correct, Gavin Harrison could quite possibly be the best drummer on the planet. And he's even better live.
Well the singer is a man named Steven Wilson who formed the band way back when. For the first 6 years he WAS Porcupine Tree- playing all instruments doing all vocals and writing. He writes about 98% of the music and lyrics, does all vocals and guitar work including writing bass and keyboard parts on some songs. I guess we'll just have to "put up" with his weak vocals :music: Personally I adore him :hearteyes: Kind of like saying I love Bob Dylan but I wish they would get a different vocalist hehe (now that I think about I bet some people do think that) :lol:
Thank you once again, Bill, for turning me onto yet another awesome band that I would otherwise never had heard of. Porcupine Tree is amazing. What a great song. Thank you Bill!
FeydBaron wrote:
Everyone is mentioning Tool, but I heard a section in there was reminded me strongly of A Perfect Circle. Don't think I'd heard this track from beginning to end before. I like it a bit better now.
Agree, but PC is essentially the same band as Tool.
This IS still the same tune! :eyes: 7, despite that.
Holy Mother of All Things Long! This is long. And absolutely bloody fantastic!!!
chiggins wrote:
bcorcoran: I haven't seen them recently, but I saw them at the Ventura Theater during the Undertow tour, and again at the Santa Barbara Bowl (which they are forbidden from ever playing again for cranking it way, way up). I've seen a lot of concerts that left me excited and babbling about how incredible they were. Both shows were the kind of experience where I was so blown away that I couldn't talk for about an hour, and I had to carry my jaw out of the show to keep it off the floor. Sucks that you saw 'em on an off night. Try again when they're on their own.
Maybe. It'll be a while though.
Everyone is mentioning Tool, but I heard a section in there was reminded me strongly of A Perfect Circle. Don\'t think I\'d heard this track from beginning to end before. I like it a bit better now.
:clap:
jadedragon wrote:
Where else would you hear a 17.5 minute song?
Must be bathroom time for Bill. :ass:
bcorcoran: I haven't seen them recently, but I saw them at the Ventura Theater during the Undertow tour, and again at the Santa Barbara Bowl (which they are forbidden from ever playing again for cranking it way, way up). I've seen a lot of concerts that left me excited and babbling about how incredible they were. Both shows were the kind of experience where I was so blown away that I couldn't talk for about an hour, and I had to carry my jaw out of the show to keep it off the floor. Sucks that you saw 'em on an off night. Try again when they're on their own.
Damn it ... I don\'t have the money to buy ALL of their CDs. ::sigh::
jadedragon wrote:
Where else would you hear a 17.5 minute song? RP rawks!
Totally. It helps that I really like the song but I just want to say THANKS again RP for playing music that doesn't fit a specific format! PT is a group that is growing on me, for sure.
Hope to see this godlike live sometime... :notworthy:
Great stuff, but I think the singer is quite weak in the whole ensemble. The drummer makes me want to practice more on my drumset! Eight eight eight!
shasta wrote:
I'd rather listen to Choctaw Bingo 3x in a row. And I gave that a 2 :grumpy:
Whoa, slow down there shasta...don't wanna pop your cork.
Dobber wrote:
Wow! Interesting comments!?! I can certainly understand not being into Tool's music because it is dark, heavy and it has the wierd time structures. They are, however, extraordinarily talented musicians. Also, they have unique sound that they are entirley responsible for creating (unlike say Porcupine Tree, who is also a great band, but sounds quite a bit like its influences). Finally, Tool has an incredibly tight live sound, and they put on the best live show that I have ever seen.
I take it you never went to Summerfest... but: Tool played their set and left. They didn't even put on a show.
7... no 2... no 8... no 2 again. argh. Interesting for sure, but comparisons to Tool aren\'t making any sense to me though.
as cartman would say \"kick ass\"
That band is a phenomenon!!! :yes:
Thanx RP! :clap:
Great band, great CD!! Thanks, RP, for introducing me to PT. (They\'re a little \"harder\" than my tastes usually run, but at my age (52), that\'s not surprising.)
I love Porcupine Tree and I really dig RP :music: Even the traditional forum trolls don\'t bother me here. Seriously everytime you get 500 people really happy about something they have in common the trolls have to come out and make their grunting noises and rude remarks. It\'s an internet tradition :yell:
Um.... wow?
My eternal thanks to Bill & RP for turning me on to PT a few years ago. I\'ve been a big fan ever since. Got to see them with Robert Fripp on the Deadwing tour - it was one of the best concerts in recent memory.
If not for RP I would have never heard PT and that would have been a loss. As it stands, I\'ve got tickets to see them in the lovely mountain setting of Asheville, NC come October. This 50-year old prog rocker can\'t wait to be the geezer in the crowd.
Where else would you hear a 17.5 minute song? RP rawks!
:hearteyes:
Bill, fantastic tune. First heard it hear, then went out and purchased this CD and In Absentia. Both phenomenal...
Wow. Rock out, Bill!
I like this album, but it\'s definitely structured to sit and listen to the thing all the way through in one sitting. The Deadwing is easier to break into song-sized pieces when you just want one great tune.
I agree with Dobber\'s comment. On PT\'s Deadwing the influence of Tool is quite obvious on certain tracks and Steven Wilson mentions Tool as an influence or \'interesting band\'on their site. I saw PT a couple of times yet (last time was june 26th in Eindhoven (NL) and again it was awesome! Great musicians and the sound was great!
The roughest song I have ever heard on RP.
bcorcoran wrote:
In my opinion Tool have become just that, tools. They put on horrible shows, too. Ask anyone who went to Summerfest. And personally I don't feel that the talent of a single member in the band really compensates for the lack of otherwise mediocre talent that is the rest of the band.
MissAmy wrote:
Wordy McWord. This is what Tool wishes they could be.
musicfreak607 wrote:
this is unbelievably better than tool
Wow! Interesting comments!?! I can certainly understand not being into Tool's music because it is dark, heavy and it has the wierd time structures. They are, however, extraordinarily talented musicians. Also, they have unique sound that they are entirley responsible for creating (unlike say Porcupine Tree, who is also a great band, but sounds quite a bit like its influences). Finally, Tool has an incredibly tight live sound, and they put on the best live show that I have ever seen.
wow, that was long.
I'd rather listen to Choctaw Bingo 3x in a row. And I gave that a 2 :grumpy:
The entity of songs building up the FOABP album with this inredible jewel in the middle is rather hard to be excelled by anything being produced in any genre today (IMHO of course). No wonder 4 of 6 tracks of this album are in RP's playlist. I bet at least one more will make it later on if not both of them. My deep respect and gratitude to Mister Wilson and PT. I'm still under the impression of the Cologne gig on June 22nd. And THX once more to Bill who dares playing gems like this in their full length glory. :clap:
daveesh wrote:
i've got two sets of soundsticks. they're great. a little pricey for what they are but i love them. bass is rich.
That's what I have on my home computer too. the whole system is great. Not quite worth the price tag.
like this a lot (most excellent)
bigB_3 wrote:
Majority rules. Open your mind & ears. :ass:
That's always a great reason to do things. Think for yourself and make your own decisions.
iTuner wrote:
Go ahead enlighten me why I'm wrong. And I'm sorry if you're the only one allowed to have an opinion on the freaking Internet. I'll stand by my opinion, the song sucks. You keep yours.
Majority rules. Open your mind & ears. :ass:
I like PT and all, but this is a bit much. Really. Would it have killed them to cut this into two songs?
bcorcoran wrote:
There are so many things wrong with your argument it isn't even worth pointing out... Moving on though, just because you don't like the song doesn't mean it isn't worth playing... bugger off. 10 for me, this song is wonderful.
Go ahead enlighten me why I'm wrong. And I'm sorry if you're the only one allowed to have an opinion on the freaking Internet. I'll stand by my opinion, the song sucks. You keep yours.
ziggytrix wrote:
i strongly disagree. this is good, but the percussion in almost any tool song blows away anything this drummer musters in this song (or any other PT i've heard for that matter). this feels like watered-down tool to me.
In my opinion Tool have become just that, tools. They put on horrible shows, too. Ask anyone who went to Summerfest. And personally I don't feel that the talent of a single member in the band really compensates for the lack of otherwise mediocre talent that is the rest of the band. PT is still better to me.
Superb. Music with feeling and imagination.
slartibart_O wrote:
Good lord I gotta get a subwoofer for this dang imac, trying to listen to the porcupine tree gods through these piddlin little built-in's just ain't hacking it. Anyone know if this salad spinner looking usb powered imac sub is worth it? (sorry to turn this into a mac blog)
i've got two sets of soundsticks. they're great. a little pricey for what they are but i love them. bass is rich.
aronson wrote:
I don't know if you can say that.
yeah, I can.
Good lord I gotta get a subwoofer for this dang imac, trying to listen to the porcupine tree gods through these piddlin little built-in's just ain't hacking it. Anyone know if this salad spinner looking usb powered imac sub is worth it? (sorry to turn this into a mac blog)
musicfreak607 wrote:
this is unbelievably better than tool
i strongly disagree. this is good, but the percussion in almost any tool song blows away anything this drummer musters in this song (or any other PT i've heard for that matter). this feels like watered-down tool to me.
Kaiser wrote:
This song kicks a significant amount of ass.
It definitely tired me out!
freddyfender wrote:
I believe the location under your name (California, baby) has a comma in there that shouldn't be.
:lol: :lol: :lol:
This song kicks a significant amount of ass.
This song has so many layers...and each one of them as intriguing as the next
:meditate:
In need some anesthectic to put up with this!!
Wow, this is really rockin'. I might just have to go find more after work today.
i love this flippin album! i know i've said it before but it somehow captures what vinyl albums used to be like.
Porcupine Tree really rocks! Another great band that RP turned me on to. Thanks Bill and Rebecca. You guys have incredible taste in music.
iTuner wrote:
I had a sculpture professor who always said "just because its big, doesn't mean its good." I think the same statement can be made about the length of a song. Zzzzzzzzzzzzzzz I feel anesthetized.
There are so many things wrong with your argument it isn't even worth pointing out... Moving on though, just because you don't like the song doesn't mean it isn't worth playing... bugger off. 10 for me, this song is wonderful.
1wolfy wrote:
great music--start to finish
Simply awesome. :drummer: :guitarist:
Johnny_Wave wrote:
Oh for f***'s sake, this song has a Part II? Tonight is obviously *not* my night to listen to RP. Perhaps I'll try again in an hour or two, but at this rate I fully expect that this crap will still be playing. Goodnight!
I believe the location under your name (California, baby) has a comma in there that shouldn't be.
Nobody's making more interesting stuff these days as SW.
lsherida wrote:
At the show I went to (Baltimore), Steven Wilson said that he found as a teenager there was a strong correlation to quality music and songs that took up the entire side of a record. It was their attempt at duplicating the phenomenon.
I had a sculpture professor who always said "just because its big, doesn't mean its good." I think the same statement can be made about the length of a song. Zzzzzzzzzzzzzzz I feel anesthetized.
great music--start to finish
Steve Wilson is The Richard Wagner of rock. This piece is not only very operatic it breaks into new territory with its combination of riffs and great sound. As our DNA twists this may be the end/perfection of what is already a fuzzy rock & roll. It is a milestone at least. We are in new territory. Hats off!
Johnny_Wave wrote:
Oh for f***'s sake, this song has a Part II? Tonight is obviously *not* my night to listen to RP. Perhaps I'll try again in an hour or two, but at this rate I fully expect that this crap will still be playing. Goodnight!
did somebody lose their binky?
Johnny_Wave wrote:
Oh for f***'s sake, this song has a Part II? Tonight is obviously *not* my night to listen to RP. Perhaps I'll try again in an hour or two, but at this rate I fully expect that this crap will still be playing. Goodnight!
wait! it`s over!
yeah, i still love rp. and i admire their abilty to do this above all else. but i still thought that song was.... over the bloody top! rade wrote:
gotta love RP for being something other than "typical" I
Oh for f***'s sake, this song has a Part II? Tonight is obviously *not* my night to listen to RP. Perhaps I'll try again in an hour or two, but at this rate I fully expect that this crap will still be playing. Goodnight!
nicolaluna wrote:
18 minutes going strong.... definitely not your typical radio song.
gotta love RP for being something other than "typical" I
not bad.... just something that long should be phenomenal.... nusrat or something. rade wrote:
that was one delicious musical nugget. more like this PLEASE bill
Silence!!! Finally!!! Sweet Silence!!!
that was one delicious musical nugget. more like this PLEASE bill
Johnny_Wave wrote:
Grr - not only is this a bad song, it never ends! Enough already
18 minutes going strong.... definitely not your typical radio song.
Grr - not only is this a bad song, it never ends! Enough already
phillips wrote:
this is the longest song ever. i think it's neverending because it sucks so bad.
At the show I went to (Baltimore), Steven Wilson said that he found as a teenager there was a strong correlation to quality music and songs that took up the entire side of a record. It was their attempt at duplicating the phenomenon. Personally, I very much like it, especially live.
hmmm, if there were more songs on rp with death metal-ish riffs int he middle like this maybe i could get my little sister to listen to rp! :hungry: (closest emoticon i can find to the two-fingered rocker fist... thing.) btw.... can somebody tell me where people chat on rp? it doesn?t seem like after the songs is the place.... thanks!
Not diggin this at all, next please
Good to hear Bill G's friendly voice after this one was over.
I don't think their bravado is misplaced one IOTA. If not perfect, then pretty damned close.
robco1 wrote:
...It is a concept album (God I love that someone still does that) about how a corrupting culture is creating a generation so alienated they become a danger to themselves and others. I think the jarring effect is very deliberate, and used to underscore the immunity to violence caused by a pop culture filled with slasher flicks and sociopatic video games.....
Hear! Hear! Maybe you need to have your otherwise peaceful life disrupted by gun-toting, bling-wearing, FASD brain-dead gang-bangers to fully appreciate this CD and in particular this song and its timely lyrics. Yes, I am referring to experiences here in suburban Burnaby, British Columbia, Canada!!! The shifting time signatures and tight percussion go beyond well beyond mere mortal adulation. A pregnant moment of sheer grace.
aronson wrote:
I have. Boston and NYC. And, I've seen them a few times before that (mostly to see Fripp of course :pray:). Not so great live but they are getting better. Regardless, the metalmoments are a bit out of space in my humble opinion.
So damn jealous! All hail the mighty Fripp! I was a semi-fan until I saw them here in Chi-town about a month ago. I don't know how they were live in the past, but they were tight as Gavin's drum-head when I saw them. They've been on heavy-rotation for me ever since.
LongGoneDaddy wrote:
somebody's been studying Neil Peart...
I don't know if you can say that. Their styles are quite different. With that said, here is your PT/Rush link du jour:
robco1 wrote:
You should see this in concert before passing final judgement.
I have. Boston and NYC. And, I've seen them a few times before that (mostly to see Fripp of course :pray:). Not so great live but they are getting better. Regardless, the metalmoments are a bit out of space in my humble opinion.
this is the longest song ever. i think it's neverending because it sucks so bad.
On a radio station dedicated to eclectic exploration of music, this embodies the meaning of eclectic. MORE!!!!
musicfreak607 wrote:
this is unbelievably better than tool
Wordy McWord. This is what Tool wishes they could be.
so freaking brilliant :sunny:
aronson wrote:
First... I love this band. Super-fabbo. With that said... I couldn't agree more. The breaks seem out of place as if Dream Theater (FEH! YUCK!) stepped into the room. Otherwise, PT is rockin. :guitarist: :bananapiano: :drummer: And, Gavin is el supremo percussioso!
You should see this in concert before passing final judgement. They played the whole album no stops, front to back. It is a concept album (God I love that someone still does that) about how a corrupting culture is creating a generation so alienated they become a danger to themselves and others. I think the jarring effect is very deliberate, and used to underscore the immunity to violence caused by a pop culture filled with slasher flicks and sociopatic video games. First listen, it wasn't my favorite PT, but with each successive it is growing on me. They have that way... And yeah, Gavin is the uber-man! Unbelievable chops.
the heavy stuff gives me a headache...
gimmee a break - drum solos suck - u can do better than shit like this
somebody's been studying Neil Peart...
this is unbelievably better than tool
Dobber wrote:
Wait a minute?!?!? I like this song a lot, I really dig Porcupine Tree and I absolutely love the music on RP. Nevertheless, if a song with elements like this makes it on RP, then it sure seems appropriate, and would be great, to also hear some Tool every once and awhile.
Now there's a comment here that I can get behind! No 4/4 any more! This one goes to 11!
First... I love this band. Super-fabbo. With that said... snowcat wrote:
Don't get me wrong I love the heavy stuff, BUT - I'm just thinking from a song-flow standpoint. They just seem out of place to me. You have this cool Floydian flow through the whole thing except twice it jolts into Gwar for no apparent reason.
I couldn't agree more. The breaks seem out of place as if Dream Theater (FEH! YUCK!) stepped into the room. Otherwise, PT is rockin. :guitarist: :bananapiano: :drummer: And, Gavin is el supremo percussioso!