Kinda like looking at the Floyd through an Orb of Phillip Glass. Weird. Sigur Rose is weird so the segue from Leit af lifi worked I guess Goldfrapp/Human is even weirder so it logics that it follows.

zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz....

It's my second time listening to (enduring) this. I just changed my 2 to a 1.

lindydallas wrote: Yepp, exactly! I like the originals more as well, even and although pigs are flying over Battersea Power Station

I'm old school...love early Floyd and Barrett...and think this is a pretty cool mix too...I respectfully disagree with my other listeners....

Stick to the original.

Eep. Coulda done without that fifteen minute interlude... --d

Unentrancing. Especially compared to the original. Ergo: remixing this as trance is redundant.

dot waits. thinks the it's coming soon. dot.

Yuck. I don't know about my grandparents, but I was an idiot for listening to the whole thing hoping it would get better. And the original gets a 10.

Hey where those Bull Frogs or Tuva throat singers in the intro. The original was *way* better than this. This one sounds like it was produced by the RIAA.

Question: Like it or not, do we really need trance remixes of old pink floyd tunes?

Art_Carnage wrote: Huh? What was that? Oh well, guess it wasn't important.... :D

Freebish wrote: i think most pink floyd is pompously painful and long. as a non fan, i could tell no difference. but i will say this... this station is for those who get sick of corporate programing and narrow mindedness. i think it's great when i finally hear a Doors tune on my local radio, only to find it's one of the same four songs that corporate radio will play of the hundreds in the Doors catalog... most pink floyd is painfully long to me, so why not hear a variation to break up the pain?

Art_Carnage wrote: I agree that the original was much better. This reminds me of a movie soundtrack.

"I'll tell you this No eternal reward will forgive us now for wasting the dawn."

Please play the original!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Man, am I torn...on the one hand, I love PF, on the other, I like songs not to last more than 6 or 7 minutes unless it's for a party remix or other unattentive purpose. This song has to be close to 15 minutes! (If not, it felt that way.) Defines a 5 in my book...neither here nor there.

This sounds to me like they have run out of ideas...

FAR superior to the original.

and after it is done....pretty cool I think

Gawd! Make it stop! Boring, tedious, without soul or merit. Why, oh Why?!? Oh wait......I'm not tripping. #-o

Please explain the purpose of this noise. The original is fine but this is a serious waste of air time. Life is far too short and to spend any of it listening to this would be a sin. :P

Yep! This goes on and on and on and on and on and on and... apparently gets nowhere, unlike the original. I'd rather like to see similar extended remix done to David Bowie's "Secret Life of Arabia" from "Heroes". At least, you can dance to that hypothetical remix, I'm quite sure. :D

Pretty f**kin' cool! I'm a floyd fan too.. and thought at first this was the real deal.. but then said.. wait.. the opening's gone on too long.... thought maybe a version I'd not heard.. then heard the drum beat start.. I'm like.. no ... no *fancy* way.. looked at it in the titlebar ... then said.. HELL YEAH !!!

Hmmm, I think this spells controversy.

Pretty f**kin\' cool! I\'m a floyd fan too.. and thought at first this was the real deal.. but then said.. wait.. the opening\'s gone on too long.... thought maybe a version I\'d not heard.. then heard the drum beat start.. I\'m like.. no ... no *fancy* way.. looked at it in the titlebar ... then said.. HELL YEAH !!!

Different