Album: BlunderbussAvg rating:
Your rating:
Total ratings: 1492
Length: 3:01
Plays (last 30 days): 2
We crossed the road and never spoke to another as we flew
We left your man alone in drag laughing there at us
A romantic bust, a blunder turned, explosive blunderbuss
An ancient grand hotel of Persian thread and ivory
And when your man would turn his head I'd see you look at me
Pools of brown and sea of red and demons in your pocket
That same romance performed a dance inside a silver locket
Da da da da
Da da da da
A corner exit not tall enough to walk out standing straight
Designed by men so ladies would have to lean back in their gait
You grabbed my arm and left with me but you were not allowed to
You took me to a public place to quietly blend into
Such a trick pretending not to be doing what you want to do
But seems like everybody does this every waking moment
I laid you down and touched you like the two of us both needed
Safe to say that others might not approve of this and pleaded
"So selfish them" would be their cry and who would be brave to argue?
Doing what two people need is never on the menu
Da da da da
Da da da da
You are not allowed to criticize this guy. He was in a documentary with Jimmy page and The Edge, and talked abut guitar playing. That means he's a great guitar player, and a great musician, and a great song writer.
I had the good fortune to see the White Stripes in concert in 2004. I didn't believe they really were a 2-person band until I saw them perform in concert. Jack White composed all the lyrics and all of the music was played. While performing, he sang, played the guitar, and played the organ all at the same time. And he played each one particularly well. I truly didn't believe it until I saw him do it live. It was amazing. So, yeah, he is a great guitar play, a great musician, and a great song writer.
RIP JLP
and
rock on JW
White is one of those artists who gets better after each listen.
You are not allowed to criticize this guy. He was in a documentary with Jimmy page and The Edge, and talked abut guitar playing. That means he's a great guitar player, and a great musician, and a great song writer.
lol. Any other rules you'd like to impose on the rest of us listeners?
good tune
Musically speaking, of course.
You are not allowed to criticize this guy. He was in a documentary with Jimmy page and The Edge, and talked abut guitar playing. That means he's a great guitar player, and a great musician, and a great song writer.
Saw that. I am a lifelong, unrepentant U2 fan. But I have to say: I'm not sure The Edge is quite in the league of the other two.
My dude has been playing the same three chords into the same reverb pedal for the last 40 years. Love it, but let's be serious.
You are not allowed to criticize this guy. He was in a documentary with Jimmy page and The Edge, and talked abut guitar playing. That means he's a great guitar player, and a great musician, and a great song writer.
Oh you're allowed. You're just liable to be rebutted.
Isis meets Small Faces
"It Might Get Loud"
Crazy good movie. The beginning shows Jack White make an electric guitar by hand and play it. What??
"It Might Get Loud"
Crazy good movie. The beginning shows Jack White make an electric guitar by hand and play it. What??
Yeah, "jangliness", I get that..
Mr. White, vs Self Parody.
Self-Parody wins this one.
AWFUL
Jack White has a much better voice and is a far better singer. (I'll get me tupperware and slink out the back door.)
LOVE the steel guitar on this one.
As much as I like Jack White and White Stripes music, I must agree with you — I'm thinking JW needs to write songs for other people to sing.
Maybe he should get Josh Groban, or Michael Buble, or maybe some contestants from American Idol sing his tunes.
And no, it doesn't sound anything like Robert Plant (whom I love)
Yes it does in a way. But it's still a "1" on my chart.
And no, it doesn't sound anything like Robert Plant (whom I love)
Propayne wrote:

A pocket-able blunderbuss, yes that's the thing.

As much as I like Jack White and White Stripes music, I must agree with you -- I'm thinking JW needs to write songs for other people to sing.
sort of grows on ya.
like a herpes sore.
Maybe. More here than just Robert Plant.
I'm not so sure about that. I do know I'd pay to hear that at least once though.
Amen brother. That's one thing that just bothers me to no end. Like, this isn't Opera. Would Pavarotti singing this song sound very good? Of course not.
I'm not so sure about that. I do know I'd pay to hear that at least once though.
(How do I scrape it off?)
The New York Times did a great piece on him and put it a little more bluntly: "(he's) notoriously bendy with the truth..." The article gives you the impression that he's very creative but always on stage.

Shades of Forbert? I looked to the screen to see what Forbert album this came from wondering how I had missed it.

All of you arm chair vocal critics slay me. Many, if not most, of the most memorable singers have voices that are "unusual". Whether you like them or not is immaterial, the public has voted and Bill apparently agrees. If you want to argue about banal lyrics, poor production, or a general lack of musical talent in a band... fine. But complaining about the voice of the lead singer is fruitless and adds nothing intelligent to the conversation.
In the end, having a great singing voice from a technical standpoint could be more of a negative than a positive. Give me Bob Dylan, Neil Young, Jack White, John Hiatt, Robert Plant, Mick Jagger, et al anyday over these pitch corrected crooners that make up the middle-of-the-road offerings in popular music.
Creativity and originality are the key (Jack White has that in spades). Maybe you need to be patronizing all of those American Idol stars that don't seem to be going anywhere after winning their "singing competition".
The fact that my opinion is stated. That's what it merely is...'an opinion'. h8rhater and anyone else for that matter can go on defending the quality of someone's voice until you're blue in the face...it won't change how people feel about his voice positive or negative. Enough goodnight!
rdo wrote:
Amen brother. That's one thing that just bothers me to no end. Like, this isn't Opera. Would Pavarotti singing this song sound very good? Of course not.
Agreed.
All of you arm chair vocal critics slay me. Many, if not most, of the most memorable singers have voices that are "unusual". Whether you like them or not is immaterial, the public has voted and Bill apparently agrees. If you want to argue about banal lyrics, poor production, or a general lack of musical talent in a band... fine. But complaining about the voice of the lead singer is fruitless and adds nothing intelligent to the conversation.
In the end, having a great singing voice from a technical standpoint could be more of a negative than a positive. Give me Bob Dylan, Neil Young, Jack White, John Hiatt, Robert Plant, Mick Jagger, et al anyday over these pitch corrected crooners that make up the middle-of-the-road offerings in popular music.
Creativity and originality are the key (Jack White has that in spades). Maybe you need to be patronizing all of those American Idol stars that don't seem to be going anywhere after winning their "singing competition".
And these people make money on their voices.
I'm not.
All of you arm chair vocal critics slay me. Many, if not most, of the most memorable singers have voices that are "unusual". Whether you like them or not is immaterial, the public has voted and Bill apparently agrees. If you want to argue about banal lyrics, poor production, or a general lack of musical talent in a band... fine. But complaining about the voice of the lead singer is fruitless and adds nothing intelligent to the conversation.
In the end, having a great singing voice from a technical standpoint could be more of a negative than a positive. Give me Bob Dylan, Neil Young, Jack White, John Hiatt, Robert Plant, Mick Jagger, et al anyday over these pitch corrected crooners that make up the middle-of-the-road offerings in popular music.
Creativity and originality are the key (Jack White has that in spades). Maybe you need to be patronizing all of those American Idol stars that don't seem to be going anywhere after winning their "singing competition".
Amen brother. That's one thing that just bothers me to no end. Like, this isn't Opera. Would Pavarotti singing this song sound very good? Of course not.
All of you arm chair vocal critics slay me. Many, if not most, of the most memorable singers have voices that are "unusual". Whether you like them or not is immaterial, the public has voted and Bill apparently agrees. If you want to argue about banal lyrics, poor production, or a general lack of musical talent in a band... fine. But complaining about the voice of the lead singer is fruitless and adds nothing intelligent to the conversation.
In the end, having a great singing voice from a technical standpoint could be more of a negative than a positive. Give me Bob Dylan, Neil Young, Jack White, John Hiatt, Robert Plant, Mick Jagger, et al anyday over these pitch corrected crooners that make up the middle-of-the-road offerings in popular music.
Creativity and originality are the key (Jack White has that in spades). Maybe you need to be patronizing all of those American Idol stars that don't seem to be going anywhere after winning their "singing competition".
I am not a composer, but have heard many artists saying some great song just came to them. I know likely the majority of music, perhaps the majority of those artist's music, required more contemplation, but I disagree that nothing really good comes without discipline. If Jack wants to just blast away and only hit it once in fifty then fine by me.
Then again, perhaps he is incredibly disciplined in resisting an urge to retool his music...oh, I am so confused now.
Read an article in the latest Electronic Musician about Jack trying to refrain from the "perfect" recordings available with Pro Tools and other modern tools, and use only analog tape machines. He's definitely old school, but that can be a good thing.
Maybe he could do a gig with Yoko Ono. Their voices ... suit each other.
and Jethro Tull ...lol
Maybe he could do a gig with Yoko Ono. Their voices ... suit each other.
I am not a composer, but have heard many artists saying some great song just came to them. I know likely the majority of music, perhaps the majority of those artist's music, required more contemplation, but I disagree that nothing really good comes without discipline. If Jack wants to just blast away and only hit it once in fifty then fine by me.
Then again, perhaps he is incredibly disciplined in resisting an urge to retool his music...oh, I am so confused now.
Ditto.
Although I understand what you're saying, it's sometimes the "character" in someone's voice that adds the extra to well-written music. I'm thinking Neil Young, Tom Waits, even Robert Plant (see the reference to Led Zepp influence in Jack's music earlier in the string) - all amazing music that is, despite not being everyone's taste, added to by the character in the voice.
Although I love what Jack does, I couldn't listen to hours of it. The tension would kill me.
Maybe you can divide music up that way, but I don't. Either a song works full sum, or it doesn't. Jack White nails it on this one.
my feelings as well.
I hear that too! Works in a new way...country rock with sweet melody!
Ryan Adamsy.
I hear that too! Works in a new way...country rock with sweet melody!
It's either there as some kind of metaphysical metaphor or to just look creepy.
Sorry RP, love ya so much, so good so consistently, I only check in to Comment for Sucko Barfo Make It Stop Make It Stop ... and Godlike. Love you, thank you!
johnjconn wrote:
yuk
.....!
or the one...leave her in your pocket, or something...
one or the other.
Silvia's Mother?
Hey, I agree—so I gave it a 4 to make the average 7.0
EDIT—someone gave it a good score so I had to drop mine to 3. I'm trying!
or the one...leave her in your pocket, or something...
one or the other.
Maybe my lad will but it?



I had the good fortune to see the White Stripes in concert in 2004. I didn't believe they really were a 2-person band until I saw them perform in concert. Jack White composed all the lyrics and all of the music was played. While performing, he sang, played the guitar, and played the organ all at the same time. And he played each one particularly well. I truly didn't believe it until I saw him do it live. It was amazing. So, yeah, he is a great guitar play, a great musician, and a great song writer.
same way Ringo is a bad drummer until someone has to play his drum work. Maybe not "The Best" but certainly not bad. Far from it. The greatness is being what was needed.
John or Paul -"Ringo, listen to this. This is what I want"
Ringo - "That's TWO drummers"