[ ]   [ ]   [ ]                        [ ]      [ ]   [ ]
Peter Mayer — Charlie Porter
Album: Million Year Mind
Avg rating:
5.9

Your rating:
Total ratings: 41









Released: 1999
Length: 3:51
Plays (last 30 days): 0
My name is Charlie Porter
I was a union soldier
In '61, I signed up to fight
And it was a great adventure
But I have to tell you
Not the fairytale I had in mind

And when General Lee surrendered
And victory finally arrived
I heard no one hoot or holler
No hip-hurray for the stars and stripes
We only cried

Back when it started
Proud and foolish hearted
I thought I had a taste for rebel blood
But we were only children
They killed us and we killed them
And the misery and the dying made us numb

By then, holding back the sorrow
Was kind of like holding back the tide
The men did not hoot or holler
Nor hip-hurray for the stars and stripes
We only cried

And oh, victory seems hollow
At the price of half a million lives
A cold and weary stillness follows
You hear no hip-hurray for stars and stripes
You only cry
Comments (4)add comment
 Sweet_Virginia wrote:
Thanks Nerubo. This makes a very powerful song even more so. Always loved LC, his music got stronger with age and his poetry never weakened or compromised. I agree with a previous reviewer, what an amazing way to go out.
 
Seems like this was meant to be a reply to You Want it Darker by Cohen, which played just previous to this son.
Thanks Nerubo. This makes a very powerful song even more so. Always loved LC, his music got stronger with age and his poetry never weakened or compromised. I agree with a previous reviewer, what an amazing way to go out.
Peter is an amazing performer - we had him stay at our house and perform one of our House Concerts - and he uses all the parts of his guitar as percussion rhythms while he's playing. Incredibly beautiful songs :)
Very lovely.