[ ]   [ ]   [ ]                        [ ]      [ ]   [ ]
The Piano Guys — Rolling In The Deep
Album: Hits Vol. 1
Avg rating:
5.4

Your rating:
Total ratings: 142









Released: 2012
Length: 3:45
Plays (last 30 days): 0
(Instrumental)
Comments (36)add comment
Brilliant.

As for the rest of you... give these guys a break  !! 
Maybe 5 years from now.  But the original is drastically oversaturated in the media.  Makes it very difficult to appreciate this cover. {#Beat}
 gvan wrote:
I feel like I'm at the world's worst wedding reception.

 
LOL
Musak
 FlatCat wrote:
Ponderous. Got no swing.
 
Yes, that's it.  It's just not a good song to do without the edge of the vocals.  They do have chops but they are applying it on the wrong song here IMNSHO
The Piano Guys are far too talented to let this be classified in the schmaltzy muzak variety. As a musician and songwriter myself, I can appreciate the arrangement and musicianship. For this, I like the Piano Guys and...yes...this cover tune.
Bill is making me hate the cello with all his cello covers.
I'm not a huge fan of the original but this pissed me off. Strikes me as a pointless waste of time.
I feel like I'm at the world's worst wedding reception.
I think they should do Eleanor Rigby instead..  there is certainly some talent here
 dyharenas wrote:
Just the one question: Why?
 
Ditto
Nice try, notice that they didn't add vocals! Ha Ha
I had to stop painting and come in to see the details on this.  I'm not sure if Awesome, Disturbing, Horrifying, or Fantastic are the right adjectives, but it sure as heck got my attention.  Wow.
Not bad would give it a second listen
 OHMish wrote:


"Now on piano!", I guess.. {#Biggrin}
 
...got that Supertramp look to it - Even In The Quietest Moments - I think
Ponderous. Got no swing.
Just the one question: Why?
For me, the set (whole) is greater than the sum of its parts.  I'm not crazy about this song by itself, but it's a nice follow from Tori Amos/"Smells Like Teen Spirit," KGB/"Call It a Night" and Ray Lamontagne/"Be Here Now."  The Tori Amos piece is my favorite of the bunch, but I wouldn't have put all this stuff together... if only because I wouldn't ever own it all. 

Pieces:  4-7 (maybe), average = 5.5
Set:  7
This hasn't improved on the original at all and it really needed some improving...
 zitherica wrote:
what's the point of this cover?
 

"Now on piano!", I guess.. {#Biggrin}
Reminds me of the days my parents played Ferrante and Teicher (sp)....
what's the point of this cover?
 ptooey wrote:
Err....excuse me.  This is my floor.
 

I recommend their Youtube channel:
https://www.youtube.com/user/thepianoguys?feature=results_main

They have some very good stuff. "Rolling In The Deep" would not be my best pick however.
Heard this track while waiting on-hold with my cellular provider.
When you've heard the real thing, this song is just a tease. Gimme vocals, now!
Expect to hear this in a elevator, not on RP.
Err....excuse me.  This is my floor.
muzak.
Heard this in the background...thought...something very familiar there.....then....ohhhh...yea...ok.  Like it so far. 

Such a shame the original got so overplayed, this was such a great song. 
um. i just don't know how to react to this.
i kind of like it...better.
I don't really see the need for this.
New version of muzak?
F A I L
Piano guys.  I hear a violin.

Ok - so any well structured pop tune is fodder for this kind of cover and Rolling in the Deep is a well structured pop song.
I wondered when these guys were going to get on RP.